2025 NFL Picks Accuracy Leaderboard : Week 5

Each week, Fantasy Nerds tracks the game predictions of the best and brightest in the NFL and compares them to the actual game outcomes. Here's how each expert compares and who is the most accurate game predictor of the 2025 NFL season.

Select a Week

Organization Expert Correct Picks
ESPN Jeremy Fowler Jeremy Fowler 1st 9
CBS Sports Pete Prisco Pete Prisco 2nd 8
ESPN Kalyn Kahler Kalyn Kahler 3rd 7
WKBW-TV Dom Tibbetts Dom Tibbetts 7
Associated Press Joe Reedy Joe Reedy 6
CBS Sports Cody Benjamin Cody Benjamin 6
CBS Sports Ryan Wilson Ryan Wilson 6
CBS Sports Tyler Sullivan Tyler Sullivan 6
Denver7 Nick Rothschild Nick Rothschild 6
ESPN Seth Wickersham Seth Wickersham 6
GoingFor2.com Geoff Lambert Geoff Lambert 6
USA Today Steve Gardner Steve Gardner 6
CBS Sports Dave Richard Dave Richard 5
CBS Sports Jared Dubin Jared Dubin 5
DraftKings DraftKings DraftKings 5
ESPN Mike Clay Mike Clay 5
ESPN Dan Graziano Dan Graziano 5
ESPN Matt Bowen Matt Bowen 5
ESPN Lindsey Thiry Lindsey Thiry 5
ESPN Eric Moody Eric Moody 5
ESPN Jason Reid Jason Reid 5
FanDuel FanDuel FanDuel 5
Fox 13 Seattle Ethan McReynolds Ethan McReynolds 5
The Sports Affiliation Greg Kellogg Greg Kellogg 5
WXIX-TV Regan Holgate Regan Holgate 5
CBS Sports Jamey Eisenberg Jamey Eisenberg 4
ESPN Pamela Maldonado Pamela Maldonado 4
ESPN Stephania Bell Stephania Bell 4
Yahoo Sports Yahoo Users Yahoo Users 4
CBS Sports John Breech John Breech 3

Past Champions

YearMost Accurate
2024Matt Bowen
ESPN
2023Doug Burrell
Gridiron Experts
2022Jamey Eisenberg (CBS Sports)
Doug Burrell (Gridiron Experts)
Nate Davis (USA Today)
2021Matt Bowen
ESPN
2020Matt Bowen
ESPN
2019Kevin Seifert
ESPN
2018Jamey Eisenberg
CBS Sports
2017Jamey Eisenberg
CBS Sports
2016Dave Richard
CBS Sports
2015Dave Richard
CBS Sports
2014Cris Carter
ESPN